Sith - 2
Thrace, Scythia
TAoW- 0
Dacia, Germania

GG's, you just played harder...

lol, you both posted the same topics within a few mins of each other :rolleyes:

i deleted the other topic so you can use this one, thanks guys :)

np :)

BTW

Scythia > DACIA

Thrace > Germania

Dont get me started in the dumbass choice of Germania vs Thrace..i forgot about the archers with little ammo... <_<

First game Sith attacks we took : Egypt pontus vs Cartage macedon

we won

Second game we took: Greece parthia vs Rome and Egypt

they won

4-2 total score now

*Reserve comment*

I have to say, I have learned allot from past games..so I am going to say good game guys..

Just to put it out, so it is no shock.."WE" "HAD" a dispute, but it is over..and all parties are contempt.

2v2 played:

SITH
Egypt/Pontus & Greece/Parthia

TAoW
Macedon/Carthage/Rome/Egypt

final is 1-1

Score is 4-2 so far...

Good Games again SITH

LoL..we are fast posters..and about your rule thingy FK

"Violation of rules
Should you notice that your opponents have broken a rule, please double-check you are right, then notify them about this politely and try to solve the issue by either agreeing on continuing the game as it is, or restarting it. Changes made to armies in the second case should be minimal, and only apply to the Rule Breaker(s).

If you notice you have broken the rule, similarly tell your opponents, and try to solve the issue by either withdrawing violating units or restarting the game, with a minimal change in armies.

Note that if you have broken the agreed/default rules, and it went unnoticed during the battle, but was discovered afterwards, you need the consent of the opposing clan to claim a victory, otherwise the battle will be played again. Of course, the victory of a team that has not broken the rules is valid even if the other team broke them.

If there is a dispute, the Staff will decide on the basis of the information in the challenge thread as well as the battle replay. It may be beneficial therefore to take Screenshots of your opponents armies after the battle for ease of viewing."

Check this in rules section...

anyone want to say what happened? :huh:

well TaOW broke a rule he took 1 archer to mush in second game he routed it so no worries

As of now

TAoW______________________________SITH

Greek/Pontus/Parthia_________________Rome/Armenia/Macedon

TAoW won

Waiting on Admins for final 3v3 outcome...

gg's!

gg 3on3 the first 1

nice sery we enjoyed it

Yes was a good serie guys,despite the games which had some disputes.I am happy to see us winning our first challenge as TAoW against one of the mightiest clans of TW.

the sery isn t closed yet

still waiting on replays :rolleyes:

please send them attatched to an email to me guys as i said last night. you needn't host it FK, just attatch it to an email and send it :)

cheers

it isnt? :rolleyes:

can someone clear up please....

are both 3v3s under dispute or just one?

if so, which one, since there seems to have been issues in both, although im not sure if they were resolved or not!

First 1 they won

ok thanks, just waiting on second game replay then - i see why its important since its decides the series.

you got my pm + i can send file over x fire or msn if you need it

we won game 1 with a clear victory.They claim there is dispute on game 2,I see no reason for dispute but anyway.

FTD had some kind of bug with his archers' formation during deployment,we told sith that we might need to restart during deployment,they said it isnt possible.

So FTD changed groupings of arhers etc. so the problem was fixed,not completely as some archers still couldnt run or get in good formaiton but FTD said it wa splayable so we went on.We asked if they agreed to restart game but they declined several times,using the example of a game vs vivv(not that I see how it was relevant to our game)

So we played game and were clearly winning,and they started saying we should restart game and it lagged etc.It lagged a little,but wasnt so bad and I could control my units without problems.

Before game ended it crashed due to a problem with FKs pc.But we clearly won it before game crash.

I will send you replay asap Titan and all 3 taow players have lots of screenshots proving we won the game.So I dont really see what the dispute is about.

I also would like to underline the fact that sith broke the rules by taking 7 of the same roman arch.I saved the logfile and anyone who was in the game can check using he logreader for themselves.I have sent Titan a screenshot showing that aswell.

I got a replay from FK - but it didnt work, so if someone could also send it, that'd be great thanks.

I couldnt take replay as the result screen closed before I could,but luckily pirx had one and he emailed it to me.I just tested it and works.Sent you a link to it via pm.

good, cause the crash made my game go down in flames...

Also, I have already sent my side of the story to Titan...So I am not going to argue issue here.

so have you watched the replay titan?

Can we get a response..before I have to leave please...

you will have an answer by the end of the day when lance and i have talked.

cheers...

HF watching it :rolleyes:

Having watched the replay of the second 3v3, we have agreed upon a decision. The game is to stand as it was, with TAoW winning the game (and therefore the series I believe). From the replay, it was hard to tell how much lagg affected the game, but we believe, from our experiences, that it would have been similar for all players. Also, since the game was not restarted, we must believe that it was playable. If it had been clearly “unplayable” then the game would have been restarted from the beginning. FK mentioned that he could not control his infantry, but, in the replay, all that he lost really was one SB unit – possibly his mistake or lagg, we couldn’t tell. However, given the position that TAoW were in at the end of the game, it was clear that one SB unit would not affect the final result.

As I said before, the result will stand, and I am sorry to Sith for this, but from the evidence we were given, we believe that it is the fairest option. If the game had been as bad as you made out, then I think you would have quit and restarted – however, from what I saw in game, you were all still able to make some decent moves and tactics, which would not have been possible if the lagg had been so bad.

In future, we will make it clear that any game which is suffering from lagg must be either played or restarted before a man is killed. The decision must be agreed between all players before the action happens so that, if needed, the game can be rehosted without affecting the battle outcome.


On a side note, we enjoyed watching the replay, looked a good game :) Although Sith-Pie Eater did break the rules and take 7 Roman Archers which Acunal noticed after the game had happened. In future, just make sure you are within the rules before pressing Go please ;)

Thank you for the fair decision Titan and thank you sith for a great serie.was a very valuable experience for us.

Enough said.... :wub: